678 Stewart Avenue · Garden City

Your pizza stop.
Right here.

Find Pizza Supreme on Stewart Avenue in Garden City. Order ahead for pickup, browse delivery options online, or give us a call.

Come find us

Pizza Supreme

678 Stewart Ave
Garden City, NY 11530

Use the map link for your route to the shop. Call for accessibility, parking details, dine-in hours, and holiday changes.

Plan your order

These are the hours listed by our online ordering system. Pickup and delivery availability is confirmed there when you order.

Before you stop by

Can I order pickup or delivery?

Yes. Use our online ordering site to choose pickup or delivery and confirm availability for your address.

How do I place a catering order?

Browse the catering menu and call (516) 228-4300 to discuss quantities and timing. Party heroes require one day’s notice and a three-foot minimum.

Does Pizza Supreme have an app?

Find Pizza Supreme on the App Store or Google Play.